Old Mill Shake Shack • Menu, Prices, & Tips
Knoebels Amusement Resort → Patio Grill

What To Expect at Old Mill Shake Shack
Snack Stand
Thick, creamy shakes and retro diner energy. A sweet pit stop that feels straight out of the 1950s.
Quick Bites
Affordable by theme park standards, with all items under $15.
No, there is no mobile ordering available at Old Mill Shake Shack.
No, there is no indoor seating at Old Mill Shake Shack.
Old Mill Shake Shack is kid-friendly.
The team is currently collecting more information regarding Old Mill Shake Shack. Updates coming shortly.
OLD MILL SHAKE SHACK MENU AND PRICES
Menus and prices updated as of April 16, 2024
Disclaimer: Menus change often. We’ll update this section as soon as we are able – check back again soon!
Classic Milkshake
7.00
Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, Banana, Cookies & Cream, Peanut Butter
Oreos
0.75
Brownie
0.75
Chocolate Chip Cookie
0.75
Cheesecake
0.75
Chocolate Sauce
0.75
Banana
0.75
Strawberry
0.75
Raspberry Puree
0.75
Peanut Butter
0.75
Caramel
0.75