Old Mill Ice Cream • Menu, Prices, & Tips
Knoebels Amusement Resort → Old Mill Shake Shack
What To Expect at Old Mill Ice Cream
Snack Stand
Homemade vibes and old-fashioned charm. Scoops, sundaes, and shakes served in a quaint, nostalgic setting.
Quick Bites
Affordable by theme park standards, with all items under $15.
No, there is no mobile ordering available at Old Mill Ice Cream.
No, there is no indoor seating at Old Mill Ice Cream.
Old Mill Ice Cream is kid-friendly.
The team is currently collecting more information regarding Old Mill Ice Cream. Updates coming shortly.
OLD MILL ICE CREAM MENU AND PRICES
Menus and prices updated as of April 16, 2024
Disclaimer: Menus change often. We’ll update this section as soon as we are able – check back again soon!
Small Cup or Cone
4.25
Large Cup or Cone
6.25
Small Waffle Cone
5.50
Large Waffle Cone
7.50
Large Float
6.00
Your favorite soda on top of vanilla ice cream, choose from Root Beer, Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Orange Crush or White Birch Beer
Cookie Sandwich
5.50
Choose your flavor ice cream sandwiched between chocolate chip cookies
Waffle Sandwich
5.50
Your favorite ice cream sandwiched between a hot homemade waffle
Hot Fudge
7.50
Vanilla ice cream topped with hot fudge, whipped cream, peanuts, and a cherry
Reese's Peanut Butter Cup
7.75
Vanilla ice cream, chopped Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, topped with peanut butter sauce, hot fudge, whipped cream, peanuts, and a cherry
Brownie
7.75
Fresh brownie with vanilla ice cream topped with hot fudge, whipped cream, peanuts, and a cherry
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
7.75
Topped with hot fudge and cookie pieces, whipped cream, peanuts, and a cherry
Strawberry Cheesecake
7.75
Strawberry and vanilla ice cream topped with strawberry topping and cheesecake pieces
Build Your Own Sundae
7.50
includes your choice of ice cream flavors, one sundae topping, whipped cream, peanuts and a cherry
Traditional Banana Split
9.00
Vanilla, chocolate and strawberry ice cream sandwiched between banana halves with chocolate, pineapple and strawberry topping, whipped cream, peanuts, and a cherry
Build Your Own Banana Split
10.00
Pick your own ice cream flavors and three toppings
Water Wheel Sundae
8.00
Pick your own ice cream flavor topped with blue mallow creme, chocolate rocks, wagon wheel pretzels and a quarter of a fresh made waffle